Close Menu

Evaluation of Three Different Enamel Roughening Method: An SEM and Photographic Study



Objective: To evaluate the effect of three different enamel roughening method on the bond strength of metal brackets bonded to enamel surfaces with light-cured composite resin, and also to determine less harmful the roughening method on the enamel by SEM and photographic methods.

Methods: Forty two metal brackets and newly extracted premolar teeth were divided into three groups (n=14 for each group). The specimens were randomly assigned to one of the following rough conditions of the teeth surfaces: Roughening with (Group 1) conventional 37% orthophosphoric acid, (Group 2) 18% HCL and pumice (microabrasion) and (Group 3) sandblasting with 50 µ alumina particles. The all surfaces were photographically examined and additional two teeth surfaces in each group were examined for SEM. Brackets were bonded to the enamel surface on the premolars with a light-polymerized resin composite. All specimens were stored in water for 1 week at 370C and then thermocycled. The shear bond strength values were measured on a universal testing machine. P values less than or equal to .05 were considered statistically significant.

Results: The specimens in Group 1 and 2 had significantly greater bond strength values. There were no statistically differences between the groups. However Group 3 showed relatively low values (7.79 ± 5.94 MPa) than the control group (P<.001). Enamel roughening method by 18% HCL and pumice gave clinically the finest enamel surface.

Conclusions: Microabrasion of the teeth with 18% HCL and pumice can be alternative tooth roughening method for bonding of brackets to enamel. After microabasion, occurred fine polished surfaces on the enamel give an easiness dental plaque control during orthodontic treatment.  

26 Mar, 2015
PDF Attachment: 
e-Published: 21 Oct, 2015


Manuscripts that are Published Ahead of Print have been peer reviewed and accepted for publication by the Editorial Board of the West Indian Medical Journal. They may appear in their original format and may not be copy edited or formatted in the style guide of this Journal. While accepted manuscripts are not yet assigned a volume, issue or page numbers, they can be cited using the DOI and date of e-publication. See our Instructions for Authors on how to properly cite manuscripts at this stage. The contents of the manuscript may change before it is published in its final form. Manuscripts in this section will be removed once they have been issued to a volume and issue, but will still retain the DOI and date of e-publication.

Top of Page